BoxyCharm alternatives: Best beauty subscription boxes like BoxyCharm

When you’re tired of the same old beauty box and want something that actually matches your skin type, style, or budget, BoxyCharm, a monthly beauty subscription box focused on full-size makeup and skincare products. Also known as premium beauty box subscription, it’s popular for its high-value hauls—but it’s not the only option out there. Many people assume BoxyCharm is the only game in town, but the truth is, there are smarter, more tailored choices that don’t cost more or deliver less.

If you’re after IPSY, a customizable beauty subscription that sends 5 personalized samples or full-size products each month. Also known as personalized beauty box, it’s ideal if you want to test new brands before buying full-size, then IPSY is a top contender. It uses your profile—skin type, concerns, favorite products—to pick items you’re likely to use. No guessing. No clutter. And at $13 a month, it’s cheaper than most BoxyCharm plans. Then there’s Birchbox, a pioneer in beauty sampling that delivers curated mini-products based on your preferences. Also known as trial beauty box, it’s perfect if you’re still exploring what works for you. Birchbox leans into discovery, while BoxyCharm pushes full-size items. Both have their place, but they serve different needs.

What makes these alternatives better isn’t just price or product size—it’s control. With BoxyCharm, you get what they decide to send. With IPSY, you pick your preferences upfront. With Birchbox, you can skip a month or change your profile anytime. And if you’re into clean beauty or sensitive skin? You’ll find more niche boxes that focus on organic, vegan, or dermatologist-tested products, like the ones we’ve covered in posts about organic skincare and non-toxic makeup. You don’t have to settle for a one-size-fits-all box when your skin doesn’t work that way.

Some people stick with BoxyCharm because they’ve always used it. Others switch after realizing they never used half the stuff. The real question isn’t whether BoxyCharm is good—it’s whether it’s right for you. What do you want? Full-size lipsticks? Skincare that actually fixes dry patches? Products that match your skin tone? The right beauty box answers those questions before you open the envelope. Below, you’ll find real reviews, breakdowns, and comparisons from people who’ve tried them all. No fluff. No sponsored posts. Just what works—and what doesn’t.